Kenny's Pizza & Subs McCaysville
Kenny's Pizza & Subs Logo

Kenny's Pizza & Subs

4.61062 reviews

Kenny's Pizza & Subs offers a cozy take-out experience. Located in McCaysville, it’s well-known for its mouthwatering pizzas and delightful subs. The menu features traditional dishes with a local twist. Perfect for a quick lunch or dinner. The staff greets everyone warmly, ensuring a pleasant experience on each visit.

About

Kenny's Pizza & Subs is situated on Toccoa Avenue, making it a convenient stop for both locals and visitors. This small pizzeria has earned a reputation for quality and flavor. The bustling kitchen prepares food to satisfy every craving. The vibrant community atmosphere draws guests in.

The location combines a laid-back vibe with great service. Its menu showcases comforting and familiar favorites, appealing to all. People pop in to grab a meal before heading to nearby attractions, including the Hiwassee River. Providing quick service, it fits seamlessly into the local dining scene.

Get in Touch

64 Toccoa Ave, McCaysville, GA 30555, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday 11:00-20:00
  • Tuesday Closed
  • Wednesday Closed
  • Thursday 11:00-20:00
  • Friday 11:00-21:00
  • Saturday 11:00-21:00
  • Sunday 11:00-20:00

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Slice was good, spaghetti was good too. The philly was just warm meat with no flavor. Just wasn't as good as I was expecting. I expected my taste buds to be blown away."

- Clint J.

"Quick & easy cheese slice with a drink ready to go! Friendly staff & cute lil place."

- Bambi H.

"Stopped in town for the layover on the Hiwassee River Scenic Railroad Excursion. Grabbed a bite here and the food was excellent. We took ours to-go and sat across the street at a picnic table. One of the cooks ran across the street just to bring us some marinara sauce that was forgotten. Excellent service overall."

- Mike L.

"Best pizza in the area hands down. New ownership. Seems be doing an awesome job Pizza calzone garlic knots. Get the buffalo garlic knots!"

- Shawn G.

"Great joint for burger and fries to share. Pizza by the slice $3.50. Very friendly too."

- Gene

"Pizza was delicious! Great sauce & crust was nice and crispy. Their Chicken bacon ranch was also delicious. Could use more seating area. Highly recommend!"

- Cat D.

"4 of us were on the blue ridge train. We got into town about 11am. We walked around a bit and went to one restaurant on the Toccoa River. We chose to dine outside, once seated, we all were shocked by the prices...$19 for a cheeseburger and it just went up $$ from there! So...we googled other places and made the short walk to Kenny's pizza and subs. Now, when we got there at about 11:55am, there was only 1 customer, sitting at the only booth. Very small, minimal seating. There was a pavillion across the street and we decided to stay put and order. The booth opened up and we sat down. Mind you...only 1 person working, 2 others called out. The young man working was the new owner. We ordered 4 meals. 1 sausage and pepper stromboli, 1 chicken parmigiana sub, 1 Turkey sub, a modified philly sub and garlic knots. They all came with home cut french fries. We All had our meals by 12:15!! And it was delicious! Homemade marinara with the knots and stromboli was authentic and fantastic! My chicken parmigiana was cooked with fresh, thick chicken tenders fried to perfection on a super soft sub roll with marinara and mozzarella cheese, it was huge, everything was! The stromboli was full of sausage, peppers and onions with plenty of mozzarella cheese. Our friends had the modified philly, and turkey cheese sub. Everything was fresh, huge and in soft sub rolls. We were All very pleased and each one of us came back with a half a sub and stromboli for dinner tonight! The fries were hot and good! They are cooked dark but definitely not burnt. I struck up a conversation with the new owner and praised him on a Very Clean kitchen area, his great cooking ability and being able to put out hot, fresh food at noon by himself! I then asked his age. He is only 36! He just bought the place a month ago. He has so much talent and seems to want to do alot cosmetically and I told him that will come with time. It is a small space but so close to the train depot that he should have great success there! He definitely needs a bigger sign and maybe someone to pass out flyers, also advertise! This little place was local, which we like anyway, and a real gem! I only wish I would have asked his name. I wish you much luck and success with your restaurant, Sir."

- Laurie B.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Kenny's Pizza & Subs is a must for pizza lovers. The extensive menu caters to various tastes. Specialty items, like chicken parmesan and stromboli, deserve a spot on anyone's table. Don't skip the garlic knots; they come highly recommended!

It's a perfect spot for a quick and satisfying meal. Avoid peak hours if possible for a more relaxed experience. Try visiting on weekdays for less wait time. The friendly staff ensures everyone feels at home, and the take-out service allows for enjoyment anywhere. Sharing a meal at a park nearby adds to the charm.

With reasonable prices, a pizza slice starts at $3.50, making it budget-friendly. Pair your meal with a refreshing drink, and it becomes a fantastic deal. The cozy atmosphere keeps locals coming back and invites tourists to join in. Whether dining solo or with friends, it's an experience worth having.

Most Liked things

The pizza has a crispy crust and flavorful sauce; many rave about the chicken bacon ranch option. Garlic knots steal the show—a perfect starter! Customers appreciate the quick service and friendly staff. The location features a relaxed vibe, enhancing the dining experience.

Most Disliked things

Some guests expressed disappointment with the flavor of the Philly cheese steak. The limited seating can be a downside, particularly during busy times. A few diners wish for more creative options on the menu. Despite this, the overall quality keeps people returning.

FAQ

What are the must-try dishes at Kenny's Pizza & Subs?

The Philly Cheese Bomb is a favorite. The Chicken Parmesan comes highly recommended too. Don't forget to try the Garlic Knots. They're perfect for sharing.

Is Kenny's Pizza & Subs kid-friendly?

Yes, Kenny's welcomes families. The menu has plenty of options that kids love, such as pizza and subs. Kids can enjoy a meal in a casual atmosphere.

What is the price range for meals here?

Most dishes at Kenny's fall within the $10 to $20 range. This makes it affordable for a casual lunch or dinner.

Do they offer takeout or delivery?

Kenny's Pizza & Subs is takeout only. They also provide delivery services for those who prefer to enjoy their meals at home.

Is there parking available at Kenny's?

Yes, there is free parking on-site and along the street. The parking lot is accessible for everyone, including those in wheelchairs.